15 Best Thrift Stores in Brooklyn for Sustainable Shopping

Last Updated on September 30, 2024 by Shavy Jain

Thrifting is embedded into the culture of America. In fact, 93% of all Americans now prefer looking through secondhand options before they make a new purchase. And we couldn’t be more grateful. Good for your pocket and the environment, thrifting is one of the best ways to promote circularity while grabbing some vintage, chic clothing and household items at affordable prices. 

From hand me downs to fancy thrift stores and round the corner goodwill huts, millions of clothes and other items are passed down from one shoulder to another. It’s the smartest way to make the full use of consumer goods, and prolong their journey towards a landfill.

If you’re based in or around Brooklyn, and want to make a run to the thrift shop yourself, then you’re in the right place. These amazing thrift stores in Brooklyn allow you to indulge in retail therapy without any guilt.

So, want to save some money, shop sustainably, or fish for cool vintage items, then check this list of 15 best Brooklyn thrift stores.

15 Best Thrift Stores in Brooklyn 

Live in Brooklyn or just visiting? You’ll have an excellent time dropping by and getting your hands on cool items from these 15 thrift stores. 

Gotham Thrift is where the cool kids hang out. Don’t believe us? Check out the incredible testimonials that this place has. The store carries a large selection of clothes, jewelry, furniture, and everything you want, and it’s stocked with fresh items every week. But the store also experiences a hefty foot traffic, so plan a trip as soon as you can.

This Williamsburg thrift store is a popular Brooklyn vintage spot on Driggs Avenue. At Monk Vintage you can find a great, curated selection of Brooklyn vintage clothing, and it has the perfect blend of vintage and trendy clothing. What’s more? You can donate your clothes at any location & receive 25% off your next purchase!

Broadway Fashion is based in the heart of Bushwick, and is home to basics and everyday essentials for all ages and sizes. The store carries the widest range of men’s and women’s fashion, with standout pieces in T-shirts, hoodies, pants, and shoes. While the store doesn’t carry luxury hand-me-downs, the store is best-known for carrying an affordable range of clothes, with prices starting as low as $6.

If vintage fashion is your cup of tea, then this is where you need to start your thrifting journey. This store carries women’s fashion, and has a large variety of bright and vibrant clothing for all seasons. With prices dipping as low as $5, affordability reigns supreme here. This hidden gem stands out as a must-visit spot and offers irresistible deals, especially for those on the hunt for vintage finds.

Le Point Value, boasting multiple locations across the five boroughs, stands out as a top contender for the most affordable thrift stores in Brooklyn, with its Prospect Lefferts Gardens branch reigning as a personal favorite. This expansive vintage emporium offers a warehouse-sized selection catering to men, women, and children alike.

Located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn Woke Vintage is a treasure trove for 80s and 90s nostalgia enthusiasts. Discover vintage vinyl, cassette tapes, action figures, and retro electronics. Reasonably priced rarities await, with an option to sell your own vintage items. While clothing options are limited, the real draw is the array of vintage toys and antiques. Don’t miss their holiday pop-up shop at Bryant Park Winter Village during Christmas in New York City!

Brooklyn Flea is a bustling outdoor flea market based just beneath the iconic Manhattan Bridge archway. Being one of our favorite thrift stores for Brooklyn natives, this lively market offers an extensive range of merchandise, from vintage clothing for men and women to furniture, antiques, Pokémon cards, and children’s toys. Additionally, local artists showcase their artwork here, providing a glimpse into the city’s emerging art scene!

Want to find some cool second-hand clothes in plus size? This Metropolitan Ave gem has the best finds for you. The store has a curated selection ranging from unique dresses to stylish leather jackets, with sizes going up to 32. Plus size patrons can also sell their clothing here for cash or store credit, which makes it the perfect place to trade off-season clothes and find chic vintage stuff in larger sizes.

The Attic is among the standout thrift stores in Brooklyn for high-end fashion finds and formal wear. Here you’ll find women’s blouses and dresses, men’s pants, Hawaiian shirts, and a weekly-updated collection of fitted caps and sneakers. While prices may vary from moderate to higher-end, the store prides itself on delivering quality finds worth every penny.

Another one of our favorite high-end, second-hand clothing thrift stores that makes the list is Crossroads Trading Co. This national chain offers a curated selection for both men and women, with fresh inventory circulating to each store almost every month. You also have the option to sell or trade your own clothing for new and second-hand pieces here at Crossroads.

L Train Vintage is another affordable thrift stores in Brooklyn, best known for its collection of vintage clothing and accessories. You’ll find great budget-friendly items including vintage apparel for both men and women. While you may not find high-end brands or formal wear here, the store has a unique collection of stuff you won’t find anywhere else in Brooklyn.

Buffalo Exchange is the best place to stay styling and sustainable. Like many thrift stores in Brooklyn, this spot has a great blend of high-end and low-end, old and brand new, vintage and trendy attire, with a focus on more recent vintage items obtained through buying, selling, and trading. Patrons have the opportunity to sell items from their own closets, either for cash or store credit towards discounted purchases, and the proceeds from transactions support various non-profit organizations aiding homelessness, animal sheltering, and environmental issues.

Grand Street Local is a Williamsburg treasure and one of the finest thrift stores in Brooklyn. This family-owned establishment boasts an extensive selection of vintage band T-shirts, sweatshirts, jackets, and more, with a distinct street sensibility that sets it apart. Be sure to keep an eye on their socials for select items that are auctioned off on the store’s Instagram page!

Beacon’s Closet is a locally owned and female-founded business, and one of our favorite thrift stores in Brooklyn. They have four locations across Brooklyn and Manhattan offering a diverse selection of secondhand treasures. You’ll find an eclectic mix of fashion here, ranging from indie to pop, neo-soul, and hip-hop.

FENG SWAY is a hidden gem nestled in Greenpoint, and a well deserved addition to our list of thrift stores in Brooklyn. This place is a haven for vintage home goods including plants, gifts, and home decor. While clothing is available, the focus here lies on greenery, unique antiques and collectibles. The prices are reasonable and we think its the perfect place to find a special gift for a loved one!

Shop Sustainably From These Affordable Brands

Who said sustainability and affordability can’t go hand in hand? If thrifting ain’t your cup of tea, then here are the top sustainable brands for you!

Thrifting Never Goes Out of Style!

The vibrant thrift stores in Brooklyn are must-visit spots for fashion enthusiasts, bargain hunters, and sustainability advocates alike. Whether you’re searching for affordable vintage finds, high-end designer labels, or unique home goods, these stores cater to every taste and budget.

Ecowiser is leading the fashion forward conversation, and we’d love for you to join us. If being Fashion Forward and shopping sustainably is in your wheelhouse, explore our Fashion Forward series right here, and check out our guide on sustainable fashion.